Menominee Indian School District’s annual meeting on Sept. 27 was, at times, contentious as almost 80 taxpayers filled up part of Menominee Indian High School’s auditorium and voted against two measures that would normally sail through an annual meeting elsewhere.
One of the measures voted down by the electorate was setting the levy, which totaled more than $5 million and included a healthy portion to pay off some of the $35 million debt the district has incurred by building a new high school, which was looming large outside the existing school. That vote failed by a slim margin, 26-28.
Attendees were frustrated to learn later in the meeting that, even though the public voted down the levy request from the district, it was only advisory in nature and that it left the Menominee Indian School Board open to set its own levy when it came to approving the budget later this fall, according to Robert Burns, the district’s attorney.
“This was a change from the legislature several years ago because there were a number of annual meetings where the tax levy was voted down,” Burns said. “The statute provides that the board has the authority, if the annual meeting does not provide an appropriate levy, that the board has the power to enact a levy on its own prior to the end of October. The levy resolution is actually an advisory resolution. It is not binding on the board.”
More voters were in the building for the second item that was voted down, the ability for the school board to acquire real estate, which was rejected by a 35-42 vote. On this matter, the district would need to call another meeting of the electorate, of which it can only call two between annual meetings, in order to ask again for approval to make deals on leasing or buying property.
The defeat comes as the district is currently talking with the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin to lease land north of the existing high school for ball fields. The reason is because the school district opted to build the new high school adjacent to the existing one, which would become the middle school building next fall once construction is complete, and required eliminating existing ball fields.
Audience members inquired about whether the real estate resolution would have any impact on the district’s ability to sell off the existing Menominee Indian Middle School in Neopit. Burns pointed out that the resolution does not restrict any decisions to dispose of property, simply to acquire it.
It was not only the voting of the two measures where signs of taxpayer frustration surfaced. During the budget hearing at the beginning of the two-hour annual meeting, Keshena resident Gregg Malmstrom stood up and claimed that he and others in the audience were not being told enough about the local taxpayer impact on the budget.
“It’s nice having all of the information from the federal government and the state government and all of those things, but you’ve told us nothing about the operating expenses this year,” Malmstrom said. “The bottom line is that you’ve really told us nothing as taxpayers that really applies to us. Everything you’ve told us is what the government is doing, so when are you exactly going to tell us what the budget is?”
As Kyla Davis, the district’s business manager, pointed out that a handout details where specific funds are, Malmstrom noted that he and others in the audience did not receive handouts. School board president David Miller interjected that audience member comments would be limited to five minutes or less, even though Malmstrom had only been speaking for less than two minutes, generating irritation from other attendees.
“Well, you better summarize quick,” Miller said to Malmstrom when the speaker noted he hadn’t been speaking for five minutes.
As more copies of the budget information were being hastily made, others in the audience questioned how they could adequately discuss and debate the budget when many didn’t have copies and there had been no ground rules established at the beginning of the meeting, such as the five-minute speaking limit. Miller claimed the five-minute limit applied at all of the board’s meetings, and when an audience member asked for there to be printed ground rules, he said there wouldn’t be for the budget hearing.
When an audience member again questioned how they could debate without having the budget information in their hands, Miller responded, “You can step out and come back later when you do have the copies.”
“It is not funny, not at all, so don’t make a joke about it,” the audience member said.
“Well, don’t make a joke out of our meeting here,” Miller replied. “We’re just asking for some civility here.”
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com
MISD electorate votes down proposed levy


