What’s in a name, or more accurately, what’s in a label?
That question raised even more questions when several dozen residents spoke out at a meeting of the Shawano Library Board, debating a recent decision to relabel Christian fiction books.
Board member Gina Shatters said she was not so much opposed to removing the cross from the book label as she was to relabeling the Christian fiction books as inspirational.
“I’m not a Christian because it’s inspirational. I’m a Christian because Jesus Christ is my lord and savior,” she said. “Nowhere in that library upstairs is any other religion placed in inspirational.”
Christian fiction books, along with other religious books, are currently labeled as faith books, but the Christian books are the only ones with the cross on them.
Several members of the public spoke in favor of leaving the cross on the books and labeling the books as Christian fiction.
“That’s just labeling something what it is,” said Jacob Schwahn, of the Town of Wescott. “If you start labeling it inspiration, you’re going to have people looking for other inspirational stuff and then finding Christian materials. I feel that cross really helps, because Christian is different than others. I see that on the side, and I know I can allow my kid to look at that.”
Schwahn said materials labeled inspirational could include matter to which he is opposed. Inspirational to some could be deemed dangerous to others.
Michael Peterson and his wife, Lana, also of the Town of Wescott, agreed.
“We believe that this is, in our opinion, censorship,” Michael Peterson said. “Inspiration is a facet of Christianity, but to us, it’s also law, science, fact. It’s a matter of faith, and it’s our personal way of making sense of our universe.”
Shawano’s Mike Richter added that inspiration is not religion.
“Inspiration can be anything, but religion is very specific,” he said. “It’s a relationship between individuals and God, whereas inspiration could be anything from walking in the woods to looking at a river or looking at an eagle or whatever the case may be.”
Lisa Bergman, of the Town of Richmond, has been a patron of the library since moving to the area 17 years ago. As a mother who homeschools her children, she relies on the library to supplement her educational materials.
“The term inspirational is somewhat meaningless in this case, because it seems to be a generic term that can embrace all different world views from Buddhism to existentialism to the follow-your-own-heart brand of humanism to ‘Chicken Soup for the Soul,’” she said. “It may seem like a small, inconsequential thing to be bickering about a little sticker, but I feel it is important.”
The Shawano County Library system generally adheres to the guidelines set by the American Library Association. According to the ALA, “While there may be some differences of opinion about which titles fit within specific genres, choosing a genre is viewpoint-neutral and does not suggest moral or doctrinal endorsement.”
The ALA opposes the use of a cross on Christian fiction books.
“This practice, especially when other religious fiction is not designated, communicates a message of preference for Christianity, which is a violation of the separation of church and state and is prohibited by the establishment clause of First Amendment as well as the Library Bill of Rights,” according to the ALA website.
“The practice of labeling Christian fiction with a cross is fundamentally different from a label bearing a ‘mystery’ or ‘western’ sticker. In recognition of this practice, some libraries seek to avoid entanglement with religion by using a label to identify materials as ‘inspirational fiction’ that may or may not have religious-based content.”
Library board members will conduct their own research into the local library practices and the ALA guidelines and discuss the issue again at the Nov. 13 meeting. The issue was not on the Oct. 9 agenda as an action item, so no decisions could legally be made.
kpasson@newmedia-wi.com
Library book labels stir controversy


