Skip to main content

Letter: Open-pit sulfide mine would be bad for environment

To the editor: My thoughts will be with the Menominee in October’s public hearing on the Aquila mine. In the best circumstances an open-pit sulfide mine is terrible for the environment, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources have lingering questions about this one. Moreover, as happens too often, tribal concerns have so far been dismissed. The promised jobs and revenue for Michigan may be enticing, and predictably Aquila Resources Inc. insists that the mine can be constructed and operated safely. We’ve heard this before. A spokesman for the Wisconsin Resources Protection Council says there’s no proof that the proposed plan can prevent acid mine drainage from contaminating the Menominee River. Added to the well-documented risks and hazards of this kind of mine is the specter of climate change, which is involved in so many of today’s social, environmental and economic problems. The unprecedented number of biblical, historic, apocalyptic, thousand-year storms and floods we’ve experienced in recent years (remember July’s storms and floods in northern Wisconsin?) is courtesy of climate change. Such an event at the proposed mine site would be calamitous. One solution would be to not build the mine. A better solution would be to not build the mine and to take decisive action to reduce carbon emissions and prevent catastrophic climate change. Green energy can offer Michigan more and better jobs and revenue than Aquila’s mine and would protect the environment and the future. Add a carbon fee whose revenue is returned to the people, and everything and everyone wins. Carol Steinhart, Madison