Skip to main content

Double homicide suspect wants more time

The Little Suamico man charged with murdering his mother and stepfather asked the judge for more time to think about whether to plead no contest to the crimes, during a brief court appearance Oct. 17. David Steinmetz, 27, faces two counts of first-degree intentional homicide and one count of possession of a firearm by a person convicted of a felony, in connection with the Oct. 1, 2022, shooting deaths of his mother, Lori Brennan, 55, and her husband, Paul Brennan, 75. The couple’s bodies were found with multiple gunshot wounds outside their home on Melissa Boulevard on the morning of Oct. 2. The investigation determined that the shootings had occurred the previous afternoon, according to the criminal complaint. Steinmetz continues to be held on $1 million cash bond at Dodge Correctional Institution in Waupun, having allegedly violated the terms of his extended supervision on multiple previous felony convictions. He had been scheduled to plead no contest during the Oct. 17 hearing before Judge Jay Conley. Court records indicate the state indicated a willingness to drop the firearms charge in exchange for pleas on the two homicides. “State will argue for life sentences with no extended supervision eligibility date,” according to the plea offer letter filed with the Oconto County Clerk of Courts. The defense is free to argue for a lesser sentence and/or a parole eligibility date, the letter said. When it came time to enter those pleas, however, Steinmetz told defense attorney Jevon Jaconi he wanted more time to think about the plea offer. Conley expressed dismay that authorities took the trouble to drive the defendant from Waupun to Oconto only to find the hearing would not take place. “All right, well, nobody’s going to be forced to do anything in this court,” Conley said. “I just wish somebody had let me know this before the sheriff’s department transported him here from prison. I feel for them.” The plea hearing was rescheduled for 1 p.m. Dec. 12. “And if there’s any problem or we’re no going to do that or we’re going to do something else, let me know before the hearing. Fair enough?” Conley said. “Understood,” Jaconi replied. The complaint said that after his arrest, Steinmetz told an investigator he had been taking methamphetamines twice a day for five days, ending with an incident in which the Brennans drove to Milwaukee to pick him up after he ran out of gas. An argument ensued when they returned to the Melissa Boulevard home that they shared, and Steinmetz left but returned and shot the couple because of a voice told him to, according to the complaint. “David stated that he had feelings that if he didn’t take his mom’s life, someone is going to take out more of his family,” the complaint said. “David stated it was like, ‘Take out one life to save 15 other lives.’” Each victim was shot several times in the driveway of the Melissa Boulevard home. wbluhm@newmedia-wi.com