It seems simple: Just toss your milk jugs and soup cans in the appropriate containers for recycling. Yet behind the scenes, it’s much more complicated.
Oconto County has run a recycling program since the 1990s when recycling was mandated by state law, partnering with municipalities to collect, process and market recyclables, plus handle the paperwork associated with the program. The county also processes materials not allowed in landfills, such as car batteries, tires, e-waste and major appliances.
In recent years, several municipalities decided to run their own programs. In August, the county’s solid waste subcommittee initially recommended ending county management of the recycling program, but pleas from municipal leaders caused them to reverse course. Several municipal leaders said they lacked the personnel to run their own programs and needed more time to transition to a municipal-run service.
In response to these requests, the County Board on Sept. 22 committed itself to three more years of managing a recycling program for interested municipalities. Supervisors, with a unanimous vote, agreed to maintain a county program, effective Jan. 1, 2017, to Dec. 31, 2019.
Supervisor Don Girardi said it made sense for the county to run the recycling program.
“The three years seems like a very reasonable length of time for the towns that go on their own to demonstrate what they can do, and it’s not an excessive length of time for those who opt to stay in the program,” he said.
Seventeen municipalities have tentatively signed on board, including the city and town of Oconto Falls, plus Stiles and Morgan.
The county will operate the program as in the past, but there’s a catch: The 17 municipalities will be responsible for any costs incurred. The enterprise fund that covered loses in recent years is depleted, and the county will pass along all costs of operating the program to the participating municipalities.
Village of Lena trustee Terry Hinds said the open-ended fiscal burden of a county-run program was a concern, because additional unanticipated costs would be borne by the municipalities.
“With the private contractors, they’ll give you a fixed amount,” he said.
Oconto County officials have prepared an anticipated cost per municipality for 2017 that includes administrative costs plus transportation and tipping fees for recyclables, with the caveat that unanticipated expenses will be passed to the municipalities.
Initially, 22 municipalities expressed interest in a county-run program. When five of them opted to manage their own recycling programs, anticipated costs for the 17 remaining municipalities rose 18 percent.
Leaders in the village and town of Lena continued to evaluate their options this week. Municipalities that contract with Oconto County must return their signed agreements by Oct. 21.
Fran Wranosky, chairman of the town of Morgan, said it was cheaper to contract with a private company than Oconto County for the first couple of years of a contract, but after that, the costs evened out.
However, cost is not the only factor the town needs to consider, he said. Private contractors offer single-stream recycling, in which recyclables can be mingled. The county-run program requires recyclables to be separated, because the county’s Materials Recovery Facility isn’t designed to process mixed recyclables.
“We have an excellent thing there in Morgan,” Wranosky said. “We’ve got great facilities. It’s beautiful, but if we go to single stream, I can see our numbers go up.”
In 2015, all but two municipalities agreed to a one-year extension of the most recent five-year recycling agreement with the county. The city of Gillett and town of Brazeau decided to run their own recycling programs for 2016, and nine additional municipalities will go this route for 2017.


