Skip to main content

County board seeks solar energy changes

The Oconto County Board is on record urging the state Legislature to change the law to again allow local units of government to regulate large-scale solar energy installations. The resolution passed Sept. 21 calls on state lawmakers to revise the statute “to grant Wisconsin counties the authority to responsibly site utility-scale solar installations in order to maintain orderly planning and comply with the statutory requirement … to adhere to the objectives, goals, and policies contained in the county’s comprehensive plan.” Supporters said a change to the law in the 1990s essentially circumvented local control by giving the state Public Service Commission the sole authority to regulate solar installations that generate 100 megawatts of power or more. “Right now the way it sits, someplace in the government they said, ‘Everything over the number of 100, we are in charge,’” Supervisor David Behrend said. “There’s no democracy for the people.” The issue has been central to the controversy over a large solar energy farm proposed by NextEra Energy LLC in the Town of Morgan. Then-Town Chairman Fran Wranosky and Supervisor Leonard Wahl were removed in a recall election for not opposing the NextEra project. Wranosky and his wife, Debbie, urged the county board to reject the resolution in a letter that was read at the beginning of the board’s Sept. 21 meeting. “This project has the potential to create a specific economic impact on the entirety of Oconto County and the Town of Morgan,” the Wranoskys wrote. “We ask that the county and its committee fully research the resolution, the project, and its probable impact on the entire county.” NextEra has proposed an annual payment to Oconto County of $350,000, or $10.5 million over 30 years, they said, and the Town of Morgan stands to gain as much as $250,000 a year or $7.5 million over 30 years, to be used at the discretion of the county and the town. The PSC and Department of Natural Resources must conduct extensive environmental and economic studies before approving any project, and NextEra must create and bond for a plan to reclaim the land for agricultural use when the installation is eventually decommissioned, wrote the Wranoskys. Supervisor Jolene Barkhaus noted that she got involved in local government because of the controversy over the solar installation. She said she has come to realize her issue isn’t with “industrial solar” itself but with the law that limits local involvement. “I get enraged about that, because it’s a slap in the face and a straight-out insult,” Barkhaus said. “It’s an insult to our zoning department, it’s an insult to our appeals board, it’s an insult to our mission/vision values team, it’s an insult to our county and our local boards’ long-term conservation plan information.” There is no reason to exclude counties or local municipalities from the regulatory process, she said. “We are entrusting these local members to make binders of regulations for your backyard patio, your home septic, your farm animals, and your business licensing, your waterfront landscape options, the list goes on, but we aren’t screaming for them to have a seat at the table when it comes to installing industrial facilities that will cover a minimum of 750 acres of land,” Barkhaus said. “Why would we let state legislators have the only say in a matter of such a large infrastructure coming to our county?” Karen Nelson-Kispert, who described herself as a 30-year resident of the Town of Morgan, said she is firmly opposed to industrial-scale solar in an agricultural zone but that’s not what this resolution is about. “Regardless of how you feel for or against industrial-scale solar in your community, this is a resolution to return the control of industrial-scale solar and wind installations back to local governments,” Nelson-Kispert said, adding that PSC commissioners “don’t have to recognize the concerns of the people from the areas that are going to be impacted the most.” Supervisor Bart Schindel expressed reservations because he said he can’t see the PSC giving up its power. “It’s going to cost millions of dollars to fight that, I think,” Schindel said. The resolution passed on a 25-2-1 vote, with Schindel and Supervisor David Christianson the only no votes. Supervisor Pat Scanlan abstained. wbluhm@newmedia-wi.com