Skip to main content

Cause of Caldwell House fire undetermined

The co-owner of the Caldwell House hopes to rebound from an Aug. 24 fire that caused extensive damage to the historic Main Street building. “I’m looking to rebuild the cafe. People are excited. They want me to,” said Pamela Ellman, who owns the building with her brother, Todd Ellman. Pamela Ellman thanked the community for its outpouring of support, including the fire crews that responded to the blaze and the people who donated items and funds to the renters displaced after the fire. She said they’re waiting for the insurance settlement to be finalized before beginning the cleanup process and committing to a rebuilding effort. The historic landmark, built in 1895 at 172 Main St., has been a boarding house and hotel, restaurant and bar. Pamela Ellman said the building’s historical significance is important to her. “I feel that I have a big commitment to the community. I love that building, and I don’t think we can walk away from it,” she said. Oconto Falls Fire Chief Tim Magnin said the fire department and Ellman’s insurance company performed a three-day investigation at the building. Interviews with tenants indicated the fire originated in a locked maintenance closet. Ladders, tools, brooms and other equipment was stored in the closet, but no chemicals. Magnin said a caretaker of the building had been in the room before noon on Aug. 24. The cause of the fire is unknown, but arson is not suspected, Magnin said. The fire caused extensive damage to the second story of the building where 17 rooms were available for rent. The nine renters living at the Caldwell House at the time of the fire have all been resettled. Ellmans opened the Caldwell Cafe in early August and planned to open The Caldwell Saloon this fall. The fire derailed those plans, at least for now.